Ranking the Playoff QBS
Don Banks sizes them
up as follows:
I disagree with those rankings. First, I'd rank Brady #1. He's got two Super Bowl MVP trophies on his shelf. Until Peyton wins a championship, there's no justification for rating him above Brady. I'd knock Roethlisberger down to the bottom of the list for now. I like Big Ben a lot, but let's see him in a playoff game before we promote him over guys who've won in the postseason.
I'd pick Pennington, who's won two playoff games over Bulger and Vick, who each have one postseason victory. And I'd put McNabb over Culpepper for similar reasons.